Sunday, September 28, 2003

New Year's Resolution: Stop the Wall!

This weekend Jews around the world have celebrated Rosh Hashana, the Jewish New Year. In Israel, authorities observed the holiday by declaring that the entire West Bank would be under military closure for three days (which was selectively enforced). Last week, the town right next to ours was declared a closed military zone, and people have not been able to access their land or begin to harvest their olives. Tractors and trucks have dumped tons of rocks and are beginning to construct something – they say they are widening the settler highway, which is quite possible, but we fear they may be clearing the way for the construction of Phase 2 of the Separation Fence / Apartheid Wall that will snake around Ariel and many other settlements, continuing to annex West Bank land into Israel.

I sit here thinking about the 50 women of Jayyus whom I met last week, whose land has been completely cut off by the Wall but who refuse to leave their homes. Many of their husbands are currently sleeping in fields on the other side of the Wall so they are able to work on their land. I think about the family in Aras / Jbarra that has been isolated from their village by the Wall, and received a notice on Thursday saying they must evacuate their home by Sunday, presumably a prelude to a house demolition. I see the maps of the proposed route of the Wall and can’t help but notice that it literally passes right by our house.

I think about all the wonderful people I know, and I think there must be a wayto stop this atrocity. So I am writing to you today to ask you to join me in acollective New Year’s resolution to stop the Wall. The Wall costs $2,000,000per kilometer, and the United States government funds Israel at a rate of over$11,000,000 a day. Bush and Congress have raised concerns about the Wall, andnow is the time to demand that none of your tax dollars go towards the buildingof this inexcusably destructive Wall. On Tuesday, September 30, Bush isexpected to announce to Congress his plans for loan guarantees to Israel. Americans, Israelis, and others will come together at the US Embassy in Tel Avivto demand an end to the funding of the Wall, and thousands of people around theUnited States will be calling on our government to stop funding apartheid inPalestine/Israel. I ask you to do the same.

I am including more facts at the bottom of this e-mail, as well as links to maps of the Wall (look in the middle of the northern West Bank where the proposed path cuts north to circle around Qedumim and east to circle around Ariel; the place whereit turns is Hares, where I live). Whether you choose to investigate this further or not, I urge you to please pick up the phone Monday or Tuesday and call Washington DC. Tell your officials that the Wall in the West Bank will not bring peace or security to Israelis or Palestinians, and that you do not want your tax dollars to fund it.

White House: phone 202-456-1111, fax 202-456-2461
State Department: phone 202-647-6575
Congress: switchboard 202-224-3121 or 800-839-5276 (www.congress.org for infoabout individual members of Congress)

The construction of Phase 1 of the Wall has:
- cut down over 100,000 Palestinian olive trees
- confiscated over 30,000 acres of Palestinian land in the northern West Bank
- demolished over 100 Palestinian houses and businesses
- caused over 80% unemployment in the city of Qalqilya
- trapped 16 Palestinian villages between the Wall and the Green Line because oftheir proximity to illegal settlements
- separated 20,000 people from their agricultural land
- confiscated or demolished over 36 ground water wells and destroyed 35,000 meters of water pipes
- forced Palestinian people to seek refuge in other countries

Maps and other info:http://www.gush-shalom.org/thewall/index.htmlhttp://www.pengon.org/wall/newmaps/poster.gif

May this year bring peace and happiness to all…Love Hannah

Wednesday, September 24, 2003

Long Days at Azzun Checkpoint

Yesterday afternoon, Kate, Carolyn and I from IWPS were on our way to visit Zahra, an amazing Palestinian woman who has been politically active for years (and was in prison for 11 years for this reason). We stopped at Azzun/Oranit checkpoint, the last checkpoint on a major road in the West Bank before entering Israel, because we heard that Palestinians detained there had been having problems. We thought we would check out the situation and be on our way within a few minutes. Little did we know we would spend three hours there. During that whole time, only about half of the 70 detained men were allowed to leave.

We could easily have driven by without noticing. The road is slightly elevated from the olive grove that stands next to it, behind large piles of rocks. Because we were looking, we noticed the men in the grove, but upon first glance, did not imagine that so many would be detained. Clearly they had been there a long time – sprawled out on the ground under trees, some playing cards, some just sitting and looking exhausted. We began talking to people, and they told us that some men had been there overnight, possibly even for two days. Most had been brought there after having been stopped on their way to work that morning (it was now 4:30 pm). Most did not have the appropriate work papers, and instead of sending them home, the border police took their IDs and told them to go sit in the field as punishment. One man, Mohammed, was trying to get into Israel to visit his son in the hospital, and a border policeman reportedly handcuffed him tightly, hit him on his face with his gun, and made him sit under the hot sun on the road. One man had his money taken from him by a border policeman who told him that money made in Israel should stay in Israel (I find it interesting that many soldiers make the distinction between Israel and Palestine when it serves their needs, and in the same conversation will say, “It’s all Israel”).

I stood there listening to story after story, getting more and more disgusted and understanding more and more the manifestations of collective punishment. Most of these men had attempted to circumvent this checkpoint, knowing they may be taking a risk but so desperate for a day’s work that they had tried anyway. Meanwhile, the border police and soldiers kept talking about Arafat, suicide bombers, and other people they considered security threats, as though their fear justified detaining 70 Palestinian men who were simply trying to make a living. “We want to live in peace,” the Palestinians repeatedly told me, clearly aware that this is not the image the world has of them. Majdi, the man who spoke English the best, told me that he used to have hope that Israelis and Palestinians could live peacefully side by side, but after the murders and house demolitions of people he knows in his hometown of Nablus, and especially after this experience, he does not think it’s possible. As a stubbornly optimistic person, I had to argue at first. We talked about the need to teach peace to children, but Majdi said, “We teach peace, we try to teach peace, but as long as this situation continues, our children will look at us and tell us we’re liars.” How can I respond to this? The men tell us all they want is to be able to live in peace, and I try to tell them that most Israelis want peace, too. They look at me with incredulity and a settler drives by and screams “Get rid of the Arabs!” Meanwhile, the police and soldiers are taunting people – honestly, acting completely childish – and the one the Palestinians call “Top Killer” is saying he wants no Palestinians in Israel. His nickname apparently comes from the detail in which he describes his work to Palestinians – explaining how he would like to shoot them and has shot people before. Clearly, many Israelis would not approve of this behavior, but it does seem to me that openly racist statements are quite common coming from Israelis, particularly in Palestine (settlers, soldiers, police). In contrast, I explain to Majdi that I am both Jewish and American (right after he tells me that Israel and the US are two places with one government), and he says, “It doesn’t matter what you are, the question is what do you want?”

But I must return to the events of the afternoon. We gave the detainees the phone number for Hamoked, an Israeli organization that tracks arrests, checkpoint detentions, and more. We made a few calls to media, but apparently they do not tend to come unless there’s blood. I was astounded that this desperate and humiliating situation was not severe enough to attract attention.

Finally, Carolyn suggested we make a banner, and I remembered that I had a sheet in my bag. Kate had a can of spray paint, so we took it out and suddenly there was a spark of excitement from the men standing around us. They immediately understood what we intended to do and wanted to make up slogans and paint the banner themselves. We discussed briefly our thoughts for the banner, and then stepped back and let them argue about their message. A couple minutes later, the banner read, “Freedom only” in English and Arabic, and “We want peace, where is our right to live?” in Hebrew. The men held up the banner and the soldiers approached them, telling them to put it away. The Palestinian men argued briefly (“What’s the problem? We want peace, it says we want peace”). When it became clear that the soldiers were not happy with this explanation, Carolyn and I took the banner to the road and held it up. The soldiers then told us that we couldn’t do this because there were more than 50 people and therefore we were having a demonstration and needed a permit. Carolyn responded with, “No, there are only three of us” referring to Kate, Carolyn, and me. Apparently the soldiers were tired of arguing, and left us alone. We held the banner for a while, and most cars slowed down to see what it said. A few yelled or gestured at us, but most simply looked and drove by. Ishmael, a man who lives right next to the checkpoint, brought us tea and talked a little about his own problems. When he told me he hasn’t had electricity for years, I pointed above his house and said, “But there are electricity lines right there.” “They’re Israeli lines,” he responded. “Who’s going to give me electricity?”

At one point, the soldiers handed back a few IDs. We asked when the rest of the men would be allowed to go, and they responded that they had let the older men go, and had orders to keep the rest (about 60) until midnight. Finally, they started returning more IDs. It was getting dark and we had to leave if we were to make it to Zahra’s house at a reasonable hour, so we said goodbye to the 30 or 40 men who were still there. I would have liked to have stayed until they were all released, but we were already late and it is almost impossible to get a car at night. Of course, this means that many men who would be released later would have to walk home.

This morning, a few IWPS people went back to that checkpoint, and found that 12 people had been there all night. I have no further information now, but clearly we will continue to watch that checkpoint.

There’s always more to say, more analysis to give, more emotion to share… but that’s all for now. I cannot know how my actions will affect situations here or anywhere, but I am confident that the more people hear stories about life in Palestine and Israel, the more likely peace becomes.

Saturday, September 20, 2003

Arrived Safely, Initial Thoughts

Dear friends,

Greetings from Hares! As you can see, I’ve arrived safely. When the plane landed in Tel Aviv and everybody clapped, I knew I was in Israel. I took a deep breath and thought about how different this trip will be than all the ones in the past…

First I want to thank you all for the incredible support you have given me in the past month as I have prepared for my trip – it gives me such strength and peace to know I have so many individuals and communities who care about me and what I’m doing.

There are currently six of us in the IWPS house, two core team members and four volunteers. I must say the house is quite nice and spacious, and we have a great view from the roof of the surrounding Palestinian villages and Jewish settlements (including Ariel, the biggest settlement in the West Bank). Our landlord, Abu Rabia, lives downstairs with his wife and two children. I played ball tonight with his younger son, Sajiyd, who is 2 and a half years old and so adorable. Abu Rabia was one of the first people in the village to start talking about the possibility of an international presence here, and continues to work with IWPS. He visited us Thursday night and our conversation varied from what we want to do about heat in the winter, to whether IWPS women would like to join 50 men from the village on a trip to Arafat’s compound in Ramallah on Friday, to the grove of trees that the Israeli army cut down that day in a neighboring village. Seeing the trees just lying there on the ground, he said, reminded him of photos of the massacres at Sabra and Shatila. The needless destruction of life… He went on to say that trees do not discriminate – that we all breathe the air they give and eat from the fruit they bear. He reminded us also that humans are the only animals who kill not only for food, and who use more than we need. Murder and greed – if only we could rid ourselves of these two faults…

I spent Friday and much of Saturday in Beit Sahor, near Bethlehem, meeting internationals who have come to work with the ISM, and participating in their training. Kate, another IWPSer, helped with the training (don’t worry, I’m not traveling alone yet!). I must say the part of the training that sticks out most in my mind was the weapons display. Ghassan, a Palestinian man who works with the ISM, dumped out a bag of weapons that we might see, and explained to us what they do. The facilitators prefaced this part by saying that it was not to freak us out, so I must also say that I am not trying to freak you out. But to watch as he showed us different types of bullets, tear gas canisters, and sound grenades, and explained different types of tanks and APCs… and then as he said about certain weapons, “But don’t worry, they only use this against Palestinians,” or “Don’t worry, they aim low at internationals,” or “They use these all the time in Gaza, but not in the West Bank”… Does that make me feel better? Should that make me feel better? And the rubber bullets – I had always thought of them as balls of rubber, bouncy and not so hard (although obviously anything shot out of a gun at a high speed can injure people). But no, “rubber bullets” are hard metal balls coated in a thin layer of rubber. The rubber was thicker during the last Intifada, Ghassan explained, but there has gradually been less and less coating.

I’m starting to get a small feel for both the everydayness and the arbitrary nature of the occupation. The checkpoints, the roadblocks, the fact that nobody seems to notice them or talk about them much unless something really egregious happens. Even I, having just arrived, followed Kate from taxi to taxi on our way to Bethlehem, and only after we got there did I stop to think, “It should not have to take 5 cars and 3 hours to travel 40 miles.” At each checkpoint or roadblock we got out, walked through, and picked up another taxi. And of course, Palestinians are used to this. As we returned to Hares this evening, we saw that police had set up a temporary checkpoint outside our village – stopping cars and buses, checking IDs. We sat down on the roadblock about 50 meters away just to watch what was happening. As we sat, Kate explained that the roadblock has been here since the start of the second Intifada, so all the cars inside Hares have been here for 3 years, and cannot get out. The cars on the outside can’t get in, so some people who do drive around park outside the village.

That’s all for now. I realize these thoughts may be slightly disjointed, but they are my initial impressions, and I know how important it is for people who are not here to hear something, anything, from people who are here. So there you have it. I will continue to be in touch and send out reports, although our internet access is quite limited at the moment.

Much love and gratitude, and prayers for peace, Hannah

Friday, August 01, 2003

Seeking Support

Dear friends, family, and members of my many communities,

Recently, as I have dedicated myself to actively defining and exploring my Jewish and American identities, I have come to the decision that the only way I can express these identities is to nonviolently resist the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. I ask you to read this letter not so that I can convince you of any particular position, but so that I can share part of the journey that has led me to this point and ask for your help in continuing it.

I have long felt a commitment to peace and justice that springs from the witnessing of pain and suffering, the experience of joy and creativity, and the desire to give from within myself. There is no one solution to the world’s problems, but at this moment, for the first time, I feel a true coincidence of what the world needs most and what I most need to do. Jews’ history as victims, fighters, and survivors in Egypt, Europe, and elsewhere can lead us in two directions: toward a sectarian view of the world in which we view our oppression as more significant than that of others, or toward solidarity with peoples who are experiencing violence around the globe. The second perspective inspires me to go to Palestine, to stop the suffering that is happening in my name as a Jew and with my money as an American. I have been to Israel several times from Jewish perspectives, but I have never experienced “the other side.” With my two months in the West Bank, I hope I am able to take a glimpse into the daily life of Palestinians under occupation, and form a more complete and grounded view for myself.

While I make this decision with strong political beliefs, my concern for peace in Israel and Palestine comes first and foremost from a deep love for humanity. When I hear talk in the Knesset [the Israeli parliament] of mass “transfer” of Palestinians, it immediately brings to mind the language of Germany in the 1930s and 1940s. When I see Sharon building a concrete wall through the middle of the West Bank, I recall the walls of the Jewish ghettos in Europe and of the Bantustans in South Africa. When army bulldozers demolish hundreds of Palestinian homes, I think of the early days of the kibbutz movement, and the “chalutzim” (pioneers) who with pride and diligence physically built up their communities. When the Israeli government uproots thousands of olive trees so that Palestinian farmers cannot sustain themselves and their families, I think of growing up instilled with the Jewish value that the earth is to be cherished (“Give money to the JNF – plant a tree in Israel”). Again and again I ask, how can we? How can we do to others what has too often been done to us? How can we destroy what we worked so hard to build?

And yet, I have hope. I have hope because I don’t know how to live without it. I have hope because just a few weeks ago, 150 Israeli peace activists climbed over roadblocks to join 150 Palestinian peace activists in Ramallah and develop a common agenda and strategy for fighting the occupation. I have hope because sixteen women from around the world have made a three-year commitment to live in the Palestinian town of Hares, engaging in work of accompaniment, protest, documentation, and grassroots organizing. It is with this group, the International Women’s Peace Service, that I will be volunteering during the olive harvest from September through November. My work will include assuring the safety of Palestinian farmers as they work in their olive groves, and picking olives there with them. I will also engage in the nonviolent struggle to stop the construction of the “separation wall,” as most Palestinians and many Israelis have come to call it, or the “security fence,” as Sharon calls it. I will document what I see and send reports to friends, family, and media. We rarely hear stories from the ground, especially stories with more than a report of violence and a body count on either side. My reports will hopefully add a touch of humanity that our mass media often neglect.

With deep hope in the possibilities for peace,
Hannah