Tuesday, March 22, 2005

Spring in Salfit, Palm Sunday in Bethlehem

Spring is here. I guess I’d thought I’d been here enough in the past couple years to be familiar with the landscape, but I’ve never been here after the winter rain, and I’ve never seen so much green. The green of the olive trees is ever-present, but the bright green grass under the trees and the landscape dotted with small flowers are new to me. It’s beautiful.

Yesterday I went to the Palestinian village of Awarta with another woman from IWPS and an Israeli group from Rabbis for Human Rights. The villagers in Awarta and Yanoun are constantly threatened and attacked by settlers from Itamar and its many outposts. On Sunday two men plowing their land in Yanoun were beaten by settlers before Rabbis for Human Rights arrived. Yesterday they went to the police station to file a report, and apparently the settlers are actually being taken in for questioning, which rarely happens. Our purpose in Awarta was to keep one eye on the farmers and one eye on the settlements above, and to do our best to make sure no attacks occurred. Indeed, it was a peaceful day, most of which I spent reading and sleeping under what Palestinians call a “Romani” olive tree, thus named because they are at least 1000 years old.

I continue to get reacquainted with people and places here. I knew one of my first stops had to be Mas’ha, so I went a few days ago to visit Munira and Hani, who live in a house that is completely surrounded by walls and fences. Any of you who have been on my list for a while or have seen me speak know the family, at least through pictures and stories. They’re some of my favorite people here. It’s a little disconcerting sometimes to know people for whom pretense is just that, especially when my Arabic isn’t always quite good enough to get beyond formalities, but it’s also refreshing to know that they’ll both tell me exactly what they think about people, governments, their situation, and life. So we chatted, drank tea and lemonade, ate fruit, and just sat. We heard loud music blaring, clearly a party of some sort, that seemed like it was coming from Mas’ha. We asked the family. “No,” they said, “It sounds like it’s coming from Mas’ha because it’s bouncing off the Wall, but it’s from the settlement.” Can’t these people have any peace? I thought. First the settlers take most of their land and build houses right next to theirs, next the Israeli government demolishes their greenhouses, next they build the Wall for “security” that cuts the family off from their village, and now they have to sit in their home and listen to settlers celebrating with obnoxiously loud music. As we were leaving, we saw a jeep sitting nearby with its doors open and soldiers hanging out, and it seemed the music was actually coming from the jeep. Either way, the Israeli occupation was celebrating itself in surround sound at the expense of the Amer family.

But celebrations come in many forms, and on Sunday I attended one of the best demonstrations I have attended here, if only because I inhaled no tear gas through my already stuffed nose. The Palm Sunday demonstration was organized mostly by Holy Land Trust, the Palestinian NGO in Bethlehem that ran the summer program I did last year [living with a family, volunteering, and learning Arabic. It’s called Palestine Summer Encounter, and they’re running it again this year – if you know people who may be interested, tell them to visit www.holylandtrust.org]. The demonstration struck at two of the most important issues to many Palestinians these days: freedom of movement, and freedom of religion. I reunited with many internationals and Palestinians whom I haven’t seen since last year, all of whom came Sunday to support the people of Bethlehem in their desire to walk from the Church of the Nativity to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre and the Al Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem, in order to pray.

We gathered in front of the Bethlehem Peace Center in Manger Square near a new installation: and uprooted olive tree. The tree is enclosed by tile walls and the encryption below reads, “I am 500 years old. I was uprooted without my permission from my original site in Bir Ona, Beit Jala, along with thousands of trees all over Palestine, to build the apartheid wall. I am still alive.”

As we prepared to march, members of a Christian international delegation began singing “We shall not be moved” and “Oh Freedom.” I always feel a bit strange about white people singing the songs that defined the African American freedom movement, not to mention the fact that this is a Palestinian struggle and “We shall not be moved” is a concept that seems almost empty if sung by people for whom movement is almost entirely self-controlled. It was nice to hear singing, though, and perhaps this contributed to a spirit that continued later with Palestinian-led singing at Tantur checkpoint.

The walk began with donkeys, children, and adults of all ages and nationalities. As we walked with balloons and banners, a truck followed with speakers blaring music, and people came out of their houses and shops to wave and smile as we passed. It felt more like a parade than a demonstration. As expected, we were stopped by soldiers at Tantur checkpoint, our numbers slightly smaller at this point as the children and donkeys had turned back to avoid risk of injury. We thought the soldiers might advance towards the space in the Wall that has yet to be completed, but we reached all the way to the checkpoint without a problem. Jeeps began to advance, soldiers started running towards us and picking up their walkie-talkies to get orders from their superiors, and we continued to walk. I had only a few moments of fear, which quickly subsided as we got close enough to the soldiers that I thought they were unlikely to throw gas (they do not generally gas themselves). I was right. The Palestinians and internationals in the front rows linked arms and approached slowly and peacefully. The soldiers formed a line across the road, linking arms as well. This standoff lasted for quite a while, punctuated by short conversations between some of the Palestinian leaders and the military commanders. One soldier had a few cartoons and the word “FREEDOM” sketched on his back. Somebody asked him, “What does the word ‘freedom’ mean to you when you’re denying these people their freedom of movement and prayer?” “I want freedom, freedom for everybody,” said the soldier. He continued to say he wished he didn’t have to do what he was doing, which led to the all-too-common interaction of “You don’t have to do it, you can refuse,” followed by “Yes I do have to do it, I’m just following orders,” followed by “You should know that argument doesn’t hold up in a court of law,” and so on. Most soldiers did their best to ignore us and not engage in conversation or take the written statement that some Palestinians were trying to give them. I looked into the eyes of some of the soldiers and wanted to cry, which is a reaction I quite often have when I’m so close to soldiers that I can see them as I should, as human beings and as kids who look just like all the kids I knew at summer camp, and who are the epitome of the Zionist ideals I believed, to some degree, when I was their age (which wasn’t so long ago).

When the army announced that the demonstration would become “illegal” in 15 minutes, and that the soldiers would then use force to remove us, the demonstrators sat down on the ground. Palestinians began to sing “We shall overcome” in English, followed by a couple Palestinian freedom songs in Arabic. As the 15 minutes neared their end, Sami Awad of Holy Land Trust stood up and delivered a beautiful statement to the soldiers who were standing right in front of him [see the statement below]. Everyone was quiet, including the soldiers, and I can only assume that some of them were listening. The organizers then announced that we would turn around and head back to Bethlehem, but that the people of Bethlehem would be back again to demand their rights.

I had mixed feelings about this ending. Although I was grateful not to face tear gas, sound bombs, or the threat of arrest, I would have liked to have seen the community attempt to advance further, to enter Jerusalem as it is their long-denied right to do. My thoughts returned to the previous day’s training and preparation, where Ghassan reminded the group that if we reach the checkpoint we must remember that the soldiers are in the way, not we, and that we are not somehow committing an offense by trying to walk to Jerusalem but the soldiers are committing an offense by trying to stop us. And still, it’s true that to some degree we knew what to expect, that if the leaders had decided to continue towards Jerusalem, we knew the soldiers would have used violence against us. Would we have been to blame, then? The clear answer to me is “No!” and yet I know as well as the organizers of the demonstration that tear gas and sound bombs are portrayed in the media as necessary tools to disperse “unruly” crowds, and that Palestinian refusal to obey the rules of occupation are portrayed as a crime, rather than the inherent criminality of occupation being portrayed as such.

So the crowd turned back, and a few of the internationals reluctantly crossed through the checkpoint “legally” to return to Jerusalem, or in our case to Hares. As we began our final shared taxi ride from Kalandia checkpoint to Hares, a man in the back seat with us took out a container of sweets and passed them around the car, making sure to pass them all the way up to the driver. “I love Palestine,” Anna said to me as she took one of the sweets. We continued to Hares in peace. I remembered Munira and Hani behind the Wall, and now the entire city of Bethlehem behind a different section of the same wall, but somehow as I shared sweets with a carload of Palestinians and listened to Arabic music, I was able to temporarily forget the occupation.

May there come a day when we can forget occupations, or remember them only as a history that we vow not to repeat. Inshallah.


Statement from people of Bethlehem to Israeli soldiers, delivered by Holy Land Trust Executive Director Sami Awad on Palm Sunday (March 20) 2005:

Asalaam ‘alaykum, dear friends,

We in the Bethlehem community have come to you today with a message on behalf of our people. We represent the family members and friends who are imprisoned by these concrete walls and wire fences that now create the Bethlehem open-air prison. You, like the prison guards, control our freedom and ability to live as human beings with dignity in this holy land.

Our strong delegation of civilians comes to you without weapons but with great strength and commitment to deliver the message of just peace. In the name of security, you do not permit us to travel to school and to worship in our holy sites in the city of Jerusalem. Your government deprives us each day of basic human rights to self-determination. Each day you keep us from being with our families at weddings, funerals, graduations, birthdays, and religious holidays. Although Al-Quds is only 20 minutes from Bethlehem, we have not been allowed to pray and worship at our holy sites for many years.

Each day as you come to our city, you serve the system of violence that keeps our people imprisoned and without the ability to live a life of a normal human being. With your guns, tanks, and insults, you teach our children to hate.

However, we believe each of you has the power and choice to choose a different ending to this story. We appeal to your conscience and humanity as individuals and as soldiers who may feel there is no way out of this system. Put your guns away—I repeat, put your guns away—and join us in the fight for peace and freedom.

The People of Bethlehem